|
|
A brain region for universal grammar?"Despite the obvious differences among human languages, all languages may be constrained by an innate 'universal grammar'--an idea long championed by the linguist Noam Chomsky. A new study shows that Broca's area, a region of the brain involved in language, becomes increasingly active as subjects acquire rules from a foreign language, but not as they acquire comparable rules that are inconsistent with real languages. The paper, in the July issue of Nature Neuroscience, concludes that Broca's area may be a neural substrate for universal grammar.""German-speaking adults learned a small vocabulary in a foreign language (Italian or Japanese). Subjects were then taught rules either consistent or inconsistent with universal grammar. While they were in an fMRI scanner, subjects were asked to judge whether test sentences followed or violated these rules. The authors report that a specific region of Broca's area became more active over time as participants became more adept with the real rules, and less active over time in response to rules that did not follow universal grammar. As Gary Marcus and colleagues discuss in an accompanying News and Views, there are several important issues that will need to be settled before concluding that Broca's area is the neural substrate for universal grammar. Nevertheless, the results are important for understanding how the brain may shape the structure of language." El artículo. Gary Marcus ya armó un pollo con esto de la gramática universal cuando publicó un artículo sobre cómo los bebés humanos generalizan reglas gramaticales. Comentaba que los datos no eran los predichos por teorías "estadísticas" del lenguaje y similares. Si os poneis a buscar encontrareis varias y varias réplicas de todo tipo, desde nuevos análisis estadísticos de los datos a simulaciones que dan nuevas explicaciones y experimentos en ratas que muestran generalización de reglas gramaticales... con luces y tonos, eso sí. Advierto que la polémica no está en que exista una localización cerebral para la gramática ;) Referencias (TrackBacks)URL de trackback de esta historia http://jkaranka.blogalia.com//trackbacks/9236
Comentarios
|
Todas las HistoriasTranslate me!Archivos
Documentos
Bitácoras Desbarradas de Akin Blog de Beor La Biblioteca de Babel El Rincón de Canopus Ciencia 15 Copensar La Cosa Húmeda Hazte Escuchar hipocondría demagógica JCantero Magonia diario del osito Por la Boca Muere el Pez El Paleofreak Segfault Tirando Líneas El Triunfo de Clío Una cuestión personal Cybergurús Epaminondas fernand0 JJMerelo Joma Jordi mini-d mur0 Laboratorios Virtuales Laboratorio Virtual de Psicología PsychExperiments Webs Homo Webensis Magufomedia ARP-SAPC Comportamental br> Neurociencias para niños Psicoteca 
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
